Analysis of The Monkeys Paw by W. W. Jacobs: A Study in Lateral Thinking

I first read The Monkey's Paw as a youngster in Junior High School. I was touched by how an elderly couple received the gift that everyone would want, three wishes, and how the gift turned into a curse.

I knew something was wrong at the beginning of the story when the previous owner tried to throw it in a fire. I also had a suspicion that though the paw granted wishes, it wouldn't work the way the person making the wish intended. Years later, I saw the Movie "Bedazzled" with Peter Cook and Dudley Moore. It's a version of the Faust legend, and hilarious. The Devil (Peter Cook), offers to trade seven wishes for Dudley Moore's character's soul. Dudley is madly in love with a young woman and is more than willing to trade something as worthless as a soul to win her. What the devil does with Moore's wishes makes for one of the funniest movies in the history of film-making. But I didn't know about "Bedazzled" in 8th Grade.

The couple, being older, quite naturally asked for money. And not a great deal, at that. They never realized that it would come as an insurance claim on the death of their son who was working in a factory. Grief-stricken, they ask for their son to come back to them. When they hear the shuffling steps and smell rotting flesh, they wish that it would go away.

What a rotten ending, right?

At the time I read it, my English Teacher, Miss Gordon, asked the class what we thought of the story. We all felt sorry for the couple. Should the couple have wished for something else with their first wish. Of course they should have, we all said. But of course, no matter what they asked for, it could have turned out as badly for them. And the previous owner had said it was a curse and not a blessing.

Miss Gordon wasn't about to stop there. Next she asked, should they have asked for son to come back to life? Of course, we all said. But not as a walking corpse.

Then came the biggest question of all. Should they have wished he wouldn't come back?

Nearly everyone in class agreed with what the couple did. That was supposed to be the end of the story.

I wasn't as eager to give up. "They wished for the wrong thing," I said.

Miss Gordon was ready to move on to a new lesson and she wasn't too pleased with me. "And how's that."

"They should have wished that the whole thing never happened because they let the man burn the monkey's paw."

"I never thought of that," my teacher said.

Today, people would call this thinking outside the box. It doesn't require great brilliance, but you do have to try to imagine other alternatives than the ones that are presented to you.

I made another teacher unhappy when I was in the 6th Grade, Miss Janitz was beginning a lesson on archeology. Everyone in the class really was eager to learn about mummies and ancient cities and she gave us a scenario where an archeologist is digging in the sand in Egypt. He finds an ancient box with a hairbrush, a necklace, and a coin dated 38 BC.

I immediately broke out laughing. All the other kids gave me a strange look but I couldn't stop. Finally Miss Janitz said, "Stop that, John. What's so funny?"

"The coin isn't real. You can't have something dated BC before there's a C.'

It turned out I had spoiled her whole three days of classes.

John Anderson has always tried to think outside the box, often with disastrous results. As a stamp dealer, he was always three years ahead of the market and seldom made a profit. He wrote a crime novel involving mitochondrial DNA five years before forensic experts began to use the procedure. His novel, The Cellini Masterpiece, and written under the penname of Raymnd John, is another example of bad timing. Its plot, which is similar to The Da Vinci code, was rejected in the mid-1980s because it was considered by some reviewers to be too unbelievable. Anyone interested in contacting him should log on to

In The News:

The Hindu

A universe of creativity
The Hindu
Creativity is a word that flows through many spheres today. Everybody seems to have jumped aboard the “Creativity Express” and there are enough workshops, seminars, programmes and classes that promise to teach one to be “creative.” While these may ...

Invent Iowa sparks creativity in students
"That's when that creativity starts to blossom," she said. Oberbroeckling said from there, students must keep an inventor's log, draw invention designs, make prototypes and create their inventions. Oberbroeckling said students competed for a chance to ...

and more »

In NoHo: Squeezing In, With Some Creativity
New York Times
In NoHo: Squeezing In, With Some Creativity. By C. J. HUGHES APRIL 18, 2014. Inside. Photo. The terra-cotta and steel 10 Bond Street, rising at Lafayette Street, will have 11 units. The building will also have a two-level townhouse that has a single ...

and more »

Palm Coast woman seeks to create community of support for creativity
Daytona Beach News-Journal
Her dedication, commitment and enthusiastic energy are perhaps exceeded only by her creativity and imagination. Frederickson wants to change the world by “creating a community to support and forward the dreams of those who wish to contribute to the ...

and more »

Mikhail Baryshnikov makes a 'Case' for restless creativity
Los Angeles Times
NEW YORK — Mikhail Baryshnikov's earliest experience in the theater began when he was a child of just 4 or 5 in present-day Latvia, then a part of the Soviet Union. His mother, a Russian speaker unfamiliar with the local tongue, would drag along her ...

'Eat Pray Love' author Elizabeth Gilbert to speak in Litchfield about ...
Torrington Register Citizen
Gilbert, a Litchfield native, will speak at Litchfield Community Center on May 1 about her thoughts on living a creative life. “Big Magic: Thoughts on a Creative Life,” is organized by the Women's Forum of Litchfield, a group which offers thought ...

Denton Record Chronicle

Creativity soon to fill park
Denton Record Chronicle
If you are an arts enthusiast of any kind, next weekend's Denton Arts & Jazz Festival will be right up your alley. The free festival, which starts Friday, is expected to attract more than 200,000 visitors over three days to Quakertown Park, where seven ...

and more »

Boredom is every child's human right. It is the fount of creativity
How's the Easter holiday going, kids? Assuming you're not grappling with the poisonous Revision Octopus, being whisked off to the Alps by economically unsqueezed parents, or enrolled in endless constructive “activities”, are you enjoying that most ...

Belleville News Democrat

Donatello's prides itself on chef's creativity
Belleville News Democrat
whips up dishes such as Chicken Breast Donatello, a boneless breast sauteed with prosciutto boursin creamed asparagus, which is served with a salad and choice of Italian roasted potatoes, fresh vegetables, baked potato or penne pasta for $16.

and more »

2 kids' creativity sparks new family business
Ahwatukee Foothills News
2 kids' creativity sparks new family business By Allison Hurtado Ahwatukee Foothills News Ahwatukee Foothills News. The creativity of two elementary-aged kids has been transformed into a family business for the LoBracco family of Ahwatukee Foothills.

Google News

Electronic Cigarettes, Electronic Pipes, Cartridges & Accessories

Electronic Cigarettes

Courage and Creating

Doing anything creative often brings up fears, anxieties, insecurities. Courage... Read More

Creating and Living Your Ideal Legacy

A legacy is more than a gift that lives on... Read More

What Every Manager Should Know About How to Think Creatively

You may have heard of Roger von Oech's book, A... Read More

Overcoming Artists Block (part 2)

Once you are ready to start working again you will... Read More

Improve Your Bottom Line, Kens Idea Saved over $100,000

Engaged employees can show us the way to continuously improve.... Read More

How You Can Improve Your Creativity - What You Need to Know

Would you like to enhance your creativity? Do you think... Read More

Becoming More Creative -- What We Can Learn From Disney

When you think about the legacies Walt Disney left us,... Read More

5 Ways to Enhance Your Creativity

We're born creative. However, this innate characteristic becomes buried as... Read More

Be Creative: 10 Easy Steps To Increase Your Confidence, Creativity and Cash In The Attention Economy

How can you be more creative? How can you turn... Read More

Inspiration, Creativity, and Channeling ? Opening Ourselves to Greatness

Channeling is much easier to do than most people suspect.... Read More

Gifts of the Inner Voice

Now that I no longer awaken to the sound of... Read More

Think Orange! Creativity and the Sacral Chakra

Wouldn't it be wonderful if you could just flick a... Read More

Tips on Breaking the Creative Block

There's no question that creating anything is hard to do.... Read More

Sharing Our Creative Work with Others

In my "Roadblocks to Creativity" e-course, I ask the question:"What's... Read More

Are You A Creative Meathead?

Remember Archie Bunker's description of what a Meathead was on... Read More

Creativity And You

95 percent of what we know about the brain, we... Read More

A New Discovery Of An Old Secret

Some years ago, when the world seemed to close in... Read More

Top Five Reasons to Cultivate Your Creativity

Cultivating your creativity is more than spending time with a... Read More

Codifying Creativity

Can we codify creativity? Within these few words are a... Read More

Are You Creative?

Have you ever heard the saying, "The harder I work,... Read More


While the inception of penicillin brought a bit of a... Read More

How To Increase Creativity... Set Deadlines!

Deadlines are something all of us face from time to... Read More

Analysis of The Monkeys Paw by W. W. Jacobs: A Study in Lateral Thinking

I first read The Monkey's Paw as a youngster in... Read More

Innovation Through Concept-Combination

There are many creative problem solving techniques used by inventors... Read More

Drawing On Creativity: How To Trick Your Brain

Can you draw?Your answer to that question reveals a surprising... Read More